On Artificial Intelligence

Oct 25, 2026

I've found a large majority of AI critics oppose AI on a moral basis, that it may replace human labor. A point I'd like to make is that all technological progress hitherto achieved by humanity has been through replacing human labor, and that replacing human labor isn't inherently bad.

The economy is defined by two things: how much we make, and how we distribute what we make. This sounds simplistic, but bear with me.

Imagine the collection of everything we output in the world, our total production. X barrels of oil, Y iPhones, Z bushels of apples. Then think about all that we input, mainly in terms of labor. I think of it like an algebraic equation in my head:

1M engineers + 70M truck drivers + 30M farmers + ... => 100M barrels of oil, 500M bushels of apples + ...

Lets say now, a company comes up a truck that drives itself between point A and point B, no human intervention needed. What would happen to our equation? Our output would stay the same, all the trucks in the world would still be doing their job, but our input would change, truck drivers would no longer be needed.

1M engineers + 0 truck drivers + 30M farmers + ... => 100M barrels of oil, 500M bushels of apples + ...

What does this mean for humanity? It means we've found a way to do more with less. Our outputs stays the same, but now we have people we can devote towards another cause. People no longer have to bear the monotony of driving a truck all day.

But as I said, the economy is defined by two things: how much we make, and how we distribute what we make. So far we've only talked about how much we're making, lets see how what we're making would be distributed.

Even though our output has stayed the same, those 70M truck drivers would now be unemployed, some would be able to reskill in the long term, but most would be left poorer and worse off in the short term. At the same time, the company that invented the self driving truck would get significantly richer. Our economic output has stayed the same, but our distribution has changed.

Depending on how you look at it, we've freed up 70M people from monotonous work, or kicked 70M people into poverty. The key distinction I'd like to make, is that in this case, the issue lies with the mode of production, not the means of production. In simpler terms, its not the AI truck thats the problem, its how we redistribute the gains from it.

This is along similar lines to what happened during the industrial revolution, where advances like the textile loom put millions of laborers out of jobs -- a machine could weave cotton faster than a human, and so humans were not needed.

A group of angry workers, calling themselves the "luddites" revolted against this by breaking machines and burning down factories. Now think about this: they were within their right to be mad, as losing their jobs meant they would be unable to provide for themselves. At the same time, imagine if we still had to do the manual labor weaving cotton by hand today. Clearly the textile loom was a net benefit for humanity, and a loss for the workers of its time.

Marx urged the luddites to look past the machines to the capitalists owning them, as I urge you to do with AI now. Think what would happen if all software was magically automated overnight. You'd have the same output, all software would maintain itself, but now you'd have a group of highly educated engineers, unburdened to apply their talents elsewhere. As it stands now, companies like OpenAI would get richer, and those workers would lose their cushy salary. But this isn't a necessity.

My final point to make is this: at no point in history has technological advancement been resisted successfully. Furthermore, it is a positive thing, and we shouldn't want to resist it anyway, as it is the fundamental driver of all advancements in living conditions. What we must be wary of is how we distribute these gains. As it stands under capitalism, gains are disproportionately dished out, but it doesn't have to be this way.